Le site buddytv.com a publié le top 10 des séries les plus degueu de la télévision et supernatural y figure en 8ème position, au côté notamment de Dexter, Bones ou encore Fringe.
"Most of the time, Supernatural keeps its frights psychological and stylish. But every show with monsters has to succumb to the disgusting occasionally. When necessary, Supernatural has effectively nauseated the audience with messy monster attacks, organs liquefied by drain cleaner, and lovers who actually eat each other."
